Wednesday, February 29, 2012
Shakespeare for the Scorched
Monday, February 27, 2012
Shakespeare for the Starved
Saturday, February 25, 2012
Shakespeare for the Secure
Shakespeare has done it again! In a few eloquent words in Macbeth, he makes a profound statement about human tendency. This is one I could see myself starting to quote, I like it so much. Though no words say it better than his, the essence is that being overconfident is dangerous to because you get lax. The quote comes from Hecate, the leader of the witches in Macbeth.
She is telling her minion witches they ought to give Macbeth visions to make him think he is invincible, which they do, which leads to his downfall. Not only is this a neat, succinct description of an aspect of human nature, but it foreshadows Macbeth’s later downfall. Without further ado, in William's very own words, I present the quote:
“Security is mortals' chiefest enemy.”
Shakespeare for the Singer
Wednesday, February 22, 2012
Shakespeare for the Sincere
"She is herself a dowry," says the French prince in response to the information that Cordelia would have no dowry. I would be hard pressed to find a more sincere expression of love in all of Shakespeare's works. Every husband and potential suitor ought to feel that way about the woman he loves. Contrast that with the countless other expressions of love in this play, many of which demonstrate a lack of sincerity, honesty, and integrity which is absolutely nauseating and heart wrenching. The play opens with declarations as nauseatingly sweet as they were blatantly false from Regan and Goneril. The king completely buys their falsity while casting out and disowning his sincere daughter who refuses to suck up. (I suppose it is fitting that the sincere Cordelia should receive such a sincere compliment from her lover. As we are so often told these days, light attracts light.) Before the scene even ends the 2 deceitful daughters are already plotting against their father. Of course there is the backwards relationship of Gloucester and his sons; again, the loyal and sincere son Edgar being ousted in favor of the deceitful and malicious son Edmond.
The French Prince's expression of love reflects more than just love but an understanding of the worth of man (or woman in this case). Such a theme is also addressed in this play, with Lear's question, "Is man no more than this?" (Act 3 scene 4) provoking further discussion of this issue. Present in the statement from the French prince is an acknowledgment of the inherent worth which Cordelia has, even without a dowry of money. Lear's question, posed after seeing poor Tom, who is devoid of all man made trimmings, implies the worthlessness of man. "Consider him well," says Lear. He points out that without the coverings that come from other animals and plants, Poor Tom demonstrates the essence of man. "Thou art the thing itself: unaccommodated man is no more but such a poor, bare, forked animal as thou art." A poor, bare, forked animal? That sentiment is a far cry from the French Prince's sentiment. The contrast reminds me of one of the best talks of all time, "You Matter to Him" by President Uchtdorf. He explores the
contrasting descriptions of the worth of man of man "The worth of souls is great in the sight of God" and "Man is nothing" with the statements "We are greater than you suppose" and "We are less than we suppose." I highly recommend the talk, and will refrain from saying anything else on the subject because President Uchtdorf says it better; but it sufficeth me to say that Shakespeare yet again hit upon one of the great questions of the soul, and yet again God's servants addressed that question perfectly with the light of the Revealed Gospel.
Wednesday, February 15, 2012
Shakespeare for the Silly
Monday, February 13, 2012
Shakespeare for Seeker of Striking Rhetoric
So our discussion in class this week motivated me to go back and finish a bunch of posts that I started but never finished, starting with this one. So when I was reading Macbeth, in addition to being super disturbed by Lady Macbeth, I made note of passages that stood out to me from a rhetorical standpoint, and here they are!
I read this just after our discussion regarding rhetorical devices and it caught my eye:
This supernatural soliciting
Cannot be ill; cannot be good: — if ill,
Why hath it given me earnest of success,
Commencing in a truth? I am Thane of Cawdor:
If good, why do I yield to that suggestion
Whose horrid image doth unfix my hair,
And make my seated heart knock at my ribs,
Against the use of nature?
The employment of alliteration here in the phrase supernatural soliciting draws attention to the strangeness of the circumstance with which Macbeth was informed of his destiny. To simply say soliciting, or supernatural message has less power than the phrase Shakespeare choose.
The following phrases also have rhetorical power—the anaphoric feel of the parallel statements he sets up with “cannot be ill; cannot be good” and the subsequent explanation of either case draws attention to the dilemma he is working through here. The witches approached him; surely he should/could act on the information which he received from their visit?
I suppose it’s not surprise to anyone that I am partial to alliteration; it seems to me the easiest of all rhetorical devices both to write and to recognize, and it lends a catchy feel to whatever phrase it graces. Consonance, the repetition of consonant sounds, not necessarily at the beginning of a word, has the same effect. The quote that follows, from Macduff, trying to convince Malcom that even though he is greedy, he has other good qualities, and other kings have been greedy, has plenty of alliteration. What is Shakespeare trying to accomplish here? What power does consonance lend this passage?
This avarice
Sticks deeper; grows with more pernicious root
Than summer-seeming lust; and it hath been
The sword of our slain kings: yet do not fear…
Maybe this is a stretch…but the thought I had was that the dominant sound in the word which is up for discussion (avarice) has an ‘s’ sound. The continual use of that same sound links the follow phrases back to that word and keeps the focus on avarice.
Ok, I admit, I mostly just like this quote because it struck my funny bone. But it’s a rhetorical device too…irony...paralipsis, anyone?
I grant him bloody,
Luxurious, avaricious, false, deceitful,
Sudden, malicious, smacking of every sin
That has a name:
Now, get ready for this next one. It’ll break your heart , once you realize the background. And the personification Ross uses here as he prepares Macduff for the news that his castle has been ransacked and his wife and sons killed struck me as quite poignant.
Let not your ears despise my tongue for ever,
Which shall possess them with the heaviest sound
That ever yet they heard.
Saturday, February 11, 2012
Shakespeare for the Shopper
Shakespeare for the Shocked
Of direst cruelty! make thick my blood,
Stop up the access and passage to remorse,
That no compunctious visitings of nature
Shake my fell purpose, nor keep peace between
The effect and it! Come to my woman's breasts,
And take my milk for gall, your murdering ministers,
Wherever in your sightless substances
You wait on nature's mischief! Come, thick night,
And pall thee in the dunnest smoke of hell
That my keen knife see not the wound it makes
Nor heaven peep through the blanket of the dark
To cry, "Hold, hold!"
Monday, February 6, 2012
Shakespeare for the Short-Attention Span
The other day in class we were talking about how in Shakespeare's day, though we don't know if they sat through complete versions of the play, we assume they sat through longer versions than we do now. Part of the reason, Professor Burton suggested, was that for them, words and speaking was their entertainment. They had longer attention spans back then and a higher tolerance for sitting through plays because that was what they did. They did not live in the world of quick and instant in which we all live, and they did not have TV, the Internet, or movies. We briefly discussed this phenomenon in class, but it reminded me of a form address given by Micheal Flaherty, president and co-founder of Walden Media back forever ago. After over half an hour of searching for this forum I remembered, I finally found his name, but could never find a transcript of his address. An MP3 of the speech can be found here or you can watch in on BYUtv here. It was a really interesting address that stood out to me because of the way that he portrayed the power that film can have in influencing people. But the thing that makes it relevant to this discussion is that he talked about how the attention span of Americans and the world is decreasing. We're starting to go away from even the 90 minute movies, and he contended the 90 second to several minute Internet videos would soon be the new medium for entertainment and sharing information. As evidence, look at the way YouTube has just appeared out of nowhere in recent years. He gave a much longer, more persuasive, and more argument than that, and I generally thought he had a valid and interesting point. So, more to the point, perhaps in this world of quick and instant in which we live, if people's attention spans really are growing shorter, Shakespeare will have to adapt to fit in with that kind of a world. Perhaps Shakespeare vignettes will become the new medium. Particularly in this class where we are exploring new mediums and cutting edge technologies along with Shakespeare, perhaps exploring how exactly Shakespeare could fit into this world would be worthwhile. I think blogging and the multitude of YouTube videos about Shakespeare are prime examples. Maybe creating several Shakespeare vignettes would be a good creative project. Mostly I'm just brainstorming, but I was intrigued by the idea trend of shortening attention spans that seems to be manifesting itself.
Shakespeare for the Speaker of the Public Variety
Shakespeare for the Sharer thereof
Shakespeare for the Sisters
Shakespeare for the Student (Evaluation)
A. Learning Outcomes
- Gain Shakespeare literacy
By reading each of the plays that we have studied thus far, I have definitely gained more Shakespeare literacy. I loved Henry V, which I had never previously studied, and I love that when people talk about the Tempest now, I’ll know what they’re talking about. The Merchant of Venice was a story I had heard before, but after having read, watched, and analyzed it, I am much more familiar with it. I have read and watched Hamlet before, but it was definitely good to look at it again with new eyes. Watching the adaptations of the works we have done definitely helped me appreciate them in a new way—watching Kenneth Branaugh’s Henry V not only helped me understand what was going on better, but gave me a more emotional connection to the characters. See my post Shakespeare for the Statuesque. Probably almost all my posts could contribute to Shakespeare Literacy, but I have specifically tagged 5 of them as being good examples of this. The legacy part of this learning outcome, becoming familiar with popular culture references, history, and scholarship acquainted with Shakespeare has almost happened without effort on my part. In many of the analysis I have done of the different plays, or when there were parts I did not understand, I would google what other people had to say on the subject and read the thoughts of several different sources. Fortunately there is an endless barrage of material about Shakespeare on the web—the only problem is that there’s so much of it, it’s easy to get lost. Because I am taking this class, I am particularly attuned to mentions of Shakespeare in popular culture, and it comes up frequently in conversation. See Shakespeare for the Social as an example.
- Analyze Shakespeare critically
Again, I have a list of blog posts that have been tagged with this phrase which provide examples of how I have analyzed Shakespeare critically. I have particularly focused on famous quotes from Shakespeare because these short pickup lines are the thing that created interest in Shakespeare for me in the first place—when I heard them used in daily life, I wanted to understand their context and be aware of them, and I believe they are the parts of Shakespeare that will stay with me the longest after I finish taking this class. When people make reference to Shakespeare, it is almost always by reference to a famous line or two. Therefore, much of my analysis has been quote based. (Shakespeare for the Seeker of Quotes and Shakespeare for the Sick.)
- Engage Shakespeare creatively
I must admit, of all the categories, this is probably the one in which I am most lacking. I had these grand ideas about incorporating running and Shakespeare, and I still plan on it, but mostly due to a series of sicknesses, I haven’t been running as much as I usually do or plan on doing this semester. But I have no doubt this will change, and there will be many more posts along the lines of Shakespeare for the Soaked, which I consider to be one example of creative engagement of Shakespeare. I also consider a blog post which I am currently working on (though I’m not sure it will be posted by this assessment) where I am re-writing the St. Crispin’s day speech in for an audience of Relief Society sisters, to be creative engagement as well.
- Share Shakespeare meaningfully
I am most pleased with my progress in this regard. Though there are only 2 posts that got tagged with this category, I feel like I am doing great here. These posts highlight a couple occasions where I have discussed Shakespeare with people outside of the class in meaningful ways, and there are many other instances that do not make it to a blog post. Making the treats with Andrew and planning a Shakespearian style dinner led to good sharing of Shakespeare meaningfully—what could be more meaningful than food? And of course interacting with people in the class, both in class and by responding to people’s comments on my blog and commenting on other people’s blogs is meaningful sharing of ideas as well. I’ve enjoyed building on thoughts of other people and thinking about their posts as well. (Shakespeare for the Satisfied as an example) It’s really quite an enjoyable way to study Shakespeare, and I’ve definitely never had a class like this before.
- Gain Digital Literacy
Embracing the art of blogging is definitely the first thing that comes to mind when I think of how I have gained digital literacy. Keeping a public blog is never something I have done before, and learning principles of good blogging and trying to apply them on my blog has been fun. I feel like I have done a decent job of blogging—the last week or so I’ve been a little slack on my blogging, but I’m getting caught up, and I feel like besides this week my blogging has been pretty consistent and reflected the things we have learned in class. If I’m understanding this learning outcome correctly, the way that I’ve looked things up on the Internet to see what other people think, both on scholarly sites as well as on more casual places like discussion boards also is an application of gaining digital literacy. See the five or so posts that are tagged accordingly.
B. Self-directed Learning
To me, self-directed learning is all about taking the initiative to do things to further one’s learning that are not mandated by the class. This means perusing avenues of learning, like researching what kind of food ate in his day, or searching for what certain words or phrases mean while reading, or looking for running based applications of Shakespeare, that might be outside of the box, or above and beyond what is required. It is all about learning about Shakespeare in a way that is personally meaningful and personally motivating. I’ve tried to do that this semester so far, and I feel that I’ve been successful so far. So whenever I think of something related to Shakespeare and think, “Boy, I wonder what that means,” or “I wonder what that would be like to think of Shakeaspeare that way,” instead of brushing the thought aside as a curiosity as I often do in other classes, I try to peruse it. I’ve likened it a bit unto my gospel study, and the way I am personally accountable for it, and am constantly seeking to improve it. It’s also fun to see what other people have done to explore the world of Shakespeare—I really liked Andrew’s idea of a Wiki, and I always enjoy reading Sarah’s posts. Kent’s love of theatre has provided him with special insight into Shakespeare, and I don’t know what he’s done specifically this semester, but his having things memorized has motivated me to have a desire to try to memorize some Shakespeare. I’m thinking about the St. Crispin’s Day Speech. Katie was telling us the definition of certain words she had looked up while reading Hamlet which added depth and context to the passage we were analyzing at the time, which I thought was a great thing to do.
C. Collaborative and Social Learning
Well, I’ve mentioned a lot of aspects of this already, how I’ve commented on the posts of others, and appreciates the posts they’ve made on my own. The last couple times I’ve posted I’ve made more of an effort to think about what they’ve written and respond thoughtfully, or even expand what they’ve said, rather than just saying, “Sweet post!” or something equally encouraging and meaningless. As I’ve mentioned, I enjoyed making treats with Andrew and collaborating with him that night, and discussing math and Shakespeare. We were excited to see that Nixon recently posted a bit all about food in Shakespeare’s day, which went along with what we’d been researching. I’ve enjoyed reading Sarah’s posts, and responding to her thoughts, as well as Rebecca’s daily blogging.
D. Looking Ahead
What more to come? I’ve mentioned a few things. More running posts is at the top of the list. Memorizing St. Crispin’s Day Speech, and re-writing, maybe even for a variety of different audiences. It might be fun to do a reading to post somewhere, if not of an entire play, of a part. I’d love to make a Shakespeare feast for the class. I always am a fan of food. So, those are some of my ideas.